Title: Gates of Stone.
Series: Lord of Islands #1.
Writer(s): Angus Macallan.
Publisher: Ace Books.
Format: Paperback (ARC).
Release Date: February 19th 2019.
Pages: 544.
Genre(s): Fantasy.
ISBN13: 9780451490278.
My Overall Rating: ★★★☆☆.
Historical fiction writer Angus Donald, the author of The Outlaw Chronicles, brings his talents into the epic fantasy game by writing under his new pen name Angus Macallan the first book of The Lord of Islands series, a high fantasy novel with a strong penchant for Asian culture and history. While the protagonists are young, the world he constructs is ruthless. With grimdark elements sporadically spread throughout the story, this is one adventure that is far from being light and casual. Although the darker moments do feel a bit out of place and unexpected, they assure readers that Angus Macallan does not plan on giving us a fairytale but a fantasy story dripping with horrible instances that will require everyone to not be faint of heart. But does Angus Macallan have what it takes to shove his way among the top tier authors in the fantasy genre today? This is his time to prove it.
What is Gates of Stone about? The story alternates between multiple characters and transports readers to different realities as their lives slowly intertwine within the islands of Laut Besar. Among these key figures is Princess Katerina, a sixteen-year-old young lady who is denied her rightful heir to the empire of the Ice-Bear because of her sex. To claim what belongs to her, she commits a dangerous crime and regains possession of her inheritance, placing her in a singular position that will force her to explore the fragile yet destructive powers she holds within the palm of her hands. Another important hero that sees his life completely changed within an instant is Prince Jun. His story brings him on an adventure to hunt down a dark sorcerer who stripped away from him everything he loved. A devious merchant known by the name of Farhan is also the center of attention as his actions hide much more than what he intends to achieve. Finally, the story also gives us an inside look at a dark sorcerer’s twisted path down into the darkness.
What Angus Macallan successfully delivers in his latest novel is an enthralling and beautiful world that has a lot of action that takes place on the sea. With pirates and whatnot roaming everywhere, danger lurks around the corner, yet is always visible to the naked eye. How he builds his world and integrates his elements of epic fantasy and mysticism are also thoroughly intelligent and compelling without giving any sense of déjà-vu. It is also worth mentioning that his attempt to create an Asian-inspired world is impeccable as the level of detail put into fully-realizing the land and the sea are impressive. Even the research put into simulating the rich Asian history and culture was authentic and helps tremendously in immersing the reader. With what Angus Macallan presents in this story, it wouldn’t be farfetched to believe that there is so much more to explore and discover in the stories to come.
Where things worked a lot less for me is with the characters. Right from the start, I was never able to connect with any of them as they never conveyed any particular traits that tickled my fancy. Often they seemed too unidimensional and functioned according to a particular way of thinking that ultimately led all their actions in one direction with barely any nuance. The lack of complexity was a bit staggering but as the story advanced, a slightly deeper appreciation for their development came to me and offered me the opportunity to overlook this in order to enjoy the story’s direction. To a lesser extent, I also found myself thrown off by some of the more historical elements that were dumped on the reader, especially when the names of people and places were pitched. In fact, a perfect example would be the historical extracts from a certain book that are placed at the beginning of some chapters that never successfully captured my attention or curiosity. Nonetheless, Angus Macallan does a wonderful job of building his world and telling his story.
Gates of Stone is a promising foray into the fantasy genre by an author with a fantastic talent in writing historical fiction and who tactically manipulates his fantasy elements to deliver a dark and action-packed story.
Thank you to Ace Books for sending me a copy for review!
It’s a beautiful looking book, shame the you didn’t connect with the characters.
LikeLiked by 2 people
It is indeed! And white tigers are my favourite animals too! 😍 At least the story was intriguing; the sequel is promising!
LikeLiked by 1 person
The few history writers who’ve turned to fantasy under pseudonyms have always disappointed me. So as soon as I saw that bit I knew I wouldn’t even think of trying this. Plus, the grimdark, not my thing 🙂
Do you think you’re going to keep on in the series, or just “see what happens”, ie, if the publishers send it to you you’ll read it, kind of thing?
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s pretty interesting, considering that solid history is a nice foundation for great fantasy stories in my mind hahah The grimdark elements were pretty ruthless in this one and sort of felt out of the blue too, I doubt you’d have appreciated it… at all. 😂
I’d gladly read the sequel if given the opportunity, but I’m not drooling for it right now hahah
LikeLiked by 1 person
My experiences have been with Miles Cameron and Naomi Novik. I couldn’t stand either of their series after a bit and since they’re both historians of a type, I’ve made that generalization now 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hmmm the pirate and sea parts still have me interested. I like worldbuilding but I am not sure I would like this one if the characters aren’t that strong. Yers is the third review I have read that all seem to have the same conclusions. I am on the fence. Lovely review.
x The Captain
LikeLiked by 1 person
I can totally understand that. There’s a bunch of sea action in here, which I did not expect to be honest. The characters are peculiar in their own ways, but I think it’s how they’re YA that made me less appealed by them in this one. I do hope you have a greater experience with it if you ever give it a shot! Thanks for reading, Capitaine! 😁
LikeLike
That’s too bad about the characters 😦 So disappointing when everything else about the book is so well done. I may bump this down the TBR now.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I wasn’t too thrilled by them, but who knows, they might work better for you, and if you do give it a try, I hope you enjoy it more than I did! 😁
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m very tempted to read this even though you had issues with the characters. But I’ve seen similar reviews from other bloggers so you’re not alone with your thoughts. Excellent review!
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s good to know that I’m not alone in this since it was a bit unfortunate considering the world-building was pretty solid! Thank you for your kind words, Tammy! 😁
LikeLike
I had similar thoughts. Though I think I ended up rating this book higher than you because I thought the second half vastly improved, I couldn’t get into any of the characters for the most part. They were either bland and boring or just horrible, horrible people.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Maaaan there really was some truly horrible scenes here and there and they really did feel like they came out of the blue too. It was almost as if scenes like those felt necessary for the author for shock-value more than anything.
LikeLike
Great review, Lashaan! I haven’t read this yet but I have it on my TBR list! It really sounds like an amazing read. I’m sorry you didn’t connect with the characters! That’s a total bummer!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you, Raven! It is a shame that I couldn’t love these characters as much as I would have liked to. I hope you do have a great time with it when you get around to i! 😁
LikeLike
Great review, Lashaan! 😊 Finding a balance between good world-building and characters is always tricky 😯 At least one of them was satisfying! 😂 The story sounds quite interesting too!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you so much, Caroline! 😀 Great authors know how to balance both or to focus on one and leave the rest in the next books too! Hopefully, the sequel will get them both right. 😛
LikeLiked by 1 person