I’ve been curious to see how Schwab’s Shades of Magic universe translated into the pages of the graphic novel and I am so sad to hear that it doesn’t capture the magic of this universe, even more so that the story of Maxim ascension to the throne lacks in substance.
Yep, I was pretty sad with the first volume myself and hoped the second would be better but I’m not impressed at all. I think hardcore fans will appreciate the attempt but no way can anyone convince me that this is flawless. 😦
The faces have dark shadows covering parts of them. It does not look well-done.
Although, I’m all for world-building on one page and then jumping into the plot straight away.
Yep, and I didn’t show the worse parts… I honestly don’t see the appeal in the style. It’s very “scratchy” and rough when I think it should’ve had a much more defined and vibrant tone to fit with the magic system…
I’m sad to see this. I read the first one and enjoyed it. But I haven’t read The Darker Shades books yet. I still may give this one a try. Great review!
I think you’re better off reading the books. I feel like the comics are just a bonus for fans and aren’t meant to be revolutionary. I still need to finish the original trilogy myself hahah Thanks for reading! 😀
V E Schwab is probably one of those authors that I haven’t read any work of yet because I feel so overwhelmed by all the glittering reviews! 😂😂 And yours has given me hope. I wasn’t exactly looking for a negative review before starting any of her series…just that….it’s a reassurance that now there is room for me to dislike what I read, should I feel like that. 😅😅
And you have made your disappointment with this one sounds so very professional that I don’t …I…..I JUST LOVED IT, OKAY!!? Yeah! 🤣🤣🤪🤩
Hahahahaha unfortunately, I can’t say the same with her novels because I love Vicious and Vengeful. I also enjoyed the first book of the Darker Shades trilogy (I still need to finish it). It’s just that if you read the books and then jump into the comics, I don’t believe you can actually be impressed by this… Hope your first attempt at a Schwab book will be positive though, Rain! 😀 Thank you so much for your kind words hahaha 😀
I read the first Shades of Magic book and I loved it because the world-building was great and the magical system airtight, but… I read her adult (NA?) book Vicious, another YA titled This Savage Song, and her first Middle Grade… City of Ghosts and hated them all. They were filled with plot conveniences, continuity problems, and huge coincidences. The magical/paranormal rules were broken half of the time to move the stories forward, and with zero explaination. To me it’s like a completely different author wrote the A Darker Shade of Magic. I plan on finishing the Shades trilogy and that will be it for Schwab and me. Ha ha. 😏
Hahahah I think This Savage Song was my favourite of her books so far. I do like when she writes adult/new adult stories as I often feel like it takes off restraints on her creativity but I am now super intrigued by what you just had to say about those books though. I’ll probably look into completing the Shades of Magic trilogy though. The first book was indeed pretty cool!
I’ve read two books in the Shades of Magic series, and as I already struggled with maintaining any interest in the second one I decided not to finish the series 😉 Seems like a good decision – especially considering that your review mightily struggles not to get down into the realm of a 1 star 😂😂
Oh no, I am 10000% certain you’d 1 star this if you had such a bad time with the books too hahahah I only read the first book and enjoyed my time with it but never got around to finishing that trilogy. You can safely avoid this comic book trilogy now hahah 😀
I intend to do precisely that! 😀
I must say I got the impression that you tried to be very gentle in your review – despite the many glaring flaws you so diligently pointed out 😉 soft spot for Schwab’s work or just general generosity? 😉
Oh wow… I totally see what you’re talking about the facial expressions!! Those are bad. The art in general looks pretty basic. I think these based on popular series comics are so all about the money that the love they need just isn’t invested in them. It sounds like the story itself isn’t good either. Personally I felt the books were pretty poor but one hopes the incredible world can support other stories.
Ohhh, there’s worse in there but it would’ve spoiled things. It’s just so unrefined and unimpressive. I would never have imagined the Darker Shades universe like this. And yes, I remember how the books disappointed you hahah I think you can skip this quite easily. 😂
I’ve heard so many good things about the Shades if Magic book series. Haven’t read them yet though 😦 Still, sorry to hear it didn’t work so well in graphic novel form.
The book trilogy is definitely that should be checked out if it intrigues you but the comic form was less than impressive so far. One more volume to be released for her to change my mind… but I doubt it’ll be any different hahah
Bookidote 
I’ve been curious to see how Schwab’s Shades of Magic universe translated into the pages of the graphic novel and I am so sad to hear that it doesn’t capture the magic of this universe, even more so that the story of Maxim ascension to the throne lacks in substance.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yep, I was pretty sad with the first volume myself and hoped the second would be better but I’m not impressed at all. I think hardcore fans will appreciate the attempt but no way can anyone convince me that this is flawless. 😦
LikeLiked by 1 person
The faces have dark shadows covering parts of them. It does not look well-done.
Although, I’m all for world-building on one page and then jumping into the plot straight away.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yep, and I didn’t show the worse parts… I honestly don’t see the appeal in the style. It’s very “scratchy” and rough when I think it should’ve had a much more defined and vibrant tone to fit with the magic system…
LikeLiked by 1 person
I keep seeing disappointed reviews of this 😦
LikeLiked by 1 person
If you ever try it, I do hope you’ll enjoy it a little bit. I just wish it was better than this… 😦
LikeLiked by 1 person
I am trying it since I loved ACoL! But I am certainly lowering my expectations!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m sad to see this. I read the first one and enjoyed it. But I haven’t read The Darker Shades books yet. I still may give this one a try. Great review!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think you’re better off reading the books. I feel like the comics are just a bonus for fans and aren’t meant to be revolutionary. I still need to finish the original trilogy myself hahah Thanks for reading! 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ll eventually get to them. The publisher sent me the first GN which is why I read it. I figured the books would be a million times better.
LikeLiked by 1 person
V E Schwab is probably one of those authors that I haven’t read any work of yet because I feel so overwhelmed by all the glittering reviews! 😂😂 And yours has given me hope. I wasn’t exactly looking for a negative review before starting any of her series…just that….it’s a reassurance that now there is room for me to dislike what I read, should I feel like that. 😅😅
And you have made your disappointment with this one sounds so very professional that I don’t …I…..I JUST LOVED IT, OKAY!!? Yeah! 🤣🤣🤪🤩
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hahahahaha unfortunately, I can’t say the same with her novels because I love Vicious and Vengeful. I also enjoyed the first book of the Darker Shades trilogy (I still need to finish it). It’s just that if you read the books and then jump into the comics, I don’t believe you can actually be impressed by this… Hope your first attempt at a Schwab book will be positive though, Rain! 😀 Thank you so much for your kind words hahaha 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
😊😊😊😊❤️❤️
LikeLiked by 1 person
I read the first Shades of Magic book and I loved it because the world-building was great and the magical system airtight, but… I read her adult (NA?) book Vicious, another YA titled This Savage Song, and her first Middle Grade… City of Ghosts and hated them all. They were filled with plot conveniences, continuity problems, and huge coincidences. The magical/paranormal rules were broken half of the time to move the stories forward, and with zero explaination. To me it’s like a completely different author wrote the A Darker Shade of Magic. I plan on finishing the Shades trilogy and that will be it for Schwab and me. Ha ha. 😏
LikeLiked by 2 people
Hahahah I think This Savage Song was my favourite of her books so far. I do like when she writes adult/new adult stories as I often feel like it takes off restraints on her creativity but I am now super intrigued by what you just had to say about those books though. I’ll probably look into completing the Shades of Magic trilogy though. The first book was indeed pretty cool!
LikeLike
I’ve read two books in the Shades of Magic series, and as I already struggled with maintaining any interest in the second one I decided not to finish the series 😉 Seems like a good decision – especially considering that your review mightily struggles not to get down into the realm of a 1 star 😂😂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh no, I am 10000% certain you’d 1 star this if you had such a bad time with the books too hahahah I only read the first book and enjoyed my time with it but never got around to finishing that trilogy. You can safely avoid this comic book trilogy now hahah 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
I intend to do precisely that! 😀
I must say I got the impression that you tried to be very gentle in your review – despite the many glaring flaws you so diligently pointed out 😉 soft spot for Schwab’s work or just general generosity? 😉
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hahahaha I think it’s a general generosity that will gradually be depleted as I get older and my reservoir for tolerance and patience shrinks 😂
LikeLiked by 1 person
I will generously ignore that unbecoming jab and pretend you talk only about yourself 😜
… This time!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hahahahahahahaha I’m dying 😂
LikeLiked by 1 person
🤣
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh wow… I totally see what you’re talking about the facial expressions!! Those are bad. The art in general looks pretty basic. I think these based on popular series comics are so all about the money that the love they need just isn’t invested in them. It sounds like the story itself isn’t good either. Personally I felt the books were pretty poor but one hopes the incredible world can support other stories.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ohhh, there’s worse in there but it would’ve spoiled things. It’s just so unrefined and unimpressive. I would never have imagined the Darker Shades universe like this. And yes, I remember how the books disappointed you hahah I think you can skip this quite easily. 😂
LikeLike
I’ve heard so many good things about the Shades if Magic book series. Haven’t read them yet though 😦 Still, sorry to hear it didn’t work so well in graphic novel form.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The book trilogy is definitely that should be checked out if it intrigues you but the comic form was less than impressive so far. One more volume to be released for her to change my mind… but I doubt it’ll be any different hahah
LikeLike
Oh no, too bad this didn’t work for you! Are you going to read the last volume, then? 😯 Great review anyway, Lashaan ❤️
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ll probably complete it for sure since it’s probably one of the shortest comics I’ve ever read and I don’t mind reading it even if it’s bad hahah
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks for sharing your review so I won’t be tempted to waste my time. 😇
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hahaha I think hardcore fans will inevitably want to check this out but if I remain objective and unbiased, this stuff is bad… 😂
LikeLike